For an oil change at home you need five things whichever way you do it: a way to get the old oil out, a filter wrench that fits your filter, a funnel, gloves and eye protection, and a sealed container to take the old oil to a collection point. The rest of the list depends on one decision. Drain from below and you also need a drain pan, a wrench or socket for the drain plug, and a safe way to raise the car. Extract from above through the dipstick tube and you need an extractor instead, but only if your engine accepts the tube.
That second route is where most "what you need" lists stop being useful. We read the instructions for four oil extractors from four sellers, and they do not agree on how warm the oil should be, and two of the four warn that the tube will not work on some engines at all. Both points decide whether the extractor belongs on your shelf.
This article covers the tools. It does not tell you when your oil is due or which oil your engine takes. Those come from your owner's manual.
Tools needed for an oil change, by route
| Tool | Drain from below | Extract from above | Why it is there |
|---|---|---|---|
| Drain pan sized above your engine's oil capacity | Yes | Only if the filter is underneath | Catches the oil and whatever the filter drips |
| Wrench or socket for the drain plug | Yes | No | Removes the plug |
| New drain plug washer or gasket, if your car uses one | Yes | No | Consumable, bought with the oil |
| Oil filter wrench | Yes | Yes | The filter still has to come off |
| Oil extractor with a tank larger than your engine's oil capacity | No | Yes | Replaces the pan and the plug |
| Ramps, or a floor jack plus jack stands, plus wheel chocks | Yes, unless there is clearance to reach without lifting | Only if the filter is underneath | Lets you reach the plug and filter without working under a jack |
| Funnel | Yes | Yes | Refilling through the filler neck |
| Nitrile gloves and safety glasses | Yes | Yes | Hot oil, drips, and debris from under the car |
| Sealed used-oil container | Yes | Yes | Transport to a collection point |
| Absorbent and shop towels | Yes | Yes | The spill that happens anyway |
Every item in the drain column has its own buying decision, and we have covered each one: how to size a pan by working capacity in our oil drain pan guide, which of the cap, band and claw designs fits your filter in oil filter wrench types, and what to do when the plug head is already rounded in the stripped drain plug guide.
Which route are you on? Check three things before you buy
Where is the oil filter? Open the hood and look. A cartridge filter in a housing on top of the engine, or a spin-on filter you can reach from above, means the extraction route can be done entirely from the top. A spin-on filter on the underside of the engine means you are going under the car anyway, with a pan to catch what the filter releases, so the extractor saves you the drain plug and nothing else.
Can you reach the drain plug without lifting? Some trucks and SUVs leave room to reach the plug from the ground. Most cars do not. If you need to lift, the lifting gear is the most expensive part of the drain route and the only part that can hurt you badly.
Does your dipstick tube accept an extractor tube? You cannot tell by looking. The Mityvac MV7201 manual says that "differences in engine blocks and dip stick configurations may make it impossible to use this equipment on every vehicle." That is the maker of the tool telling you the tool may not work on your car.
What four extractor makers' instructions actually say
We read the instructions published for four manual oil extractors on November 10, 2026: the Mityvac MV7201 (two editions of its manual), the Motive Products Power Extractor, the Griot's Garage Oil/Liquid Extractor and the West Marine Extractor, model 11097714. This is a document review. We did not run any of these tools.
| Extractor | How warm the oil should be | Stated temperature limit | What it says about tube fit | Tank size stated |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mityvac MV7201 (both editions) | Idle the engine "until it reaches normal operating temperature" | SKF edition: "Do not extract oil when temperature is above 176 °F (80 °C)"; 2010 edition: 175 °F in its spec line, 176 °F in its fluids section | Do not force a tube the dipstick tube does not readily accept | 8.8 liters in the 2010 edition; empty and restart if the crankcase holds more than 8 liters |
| Motive Products Power Extractor | Run the engine a few minutes; if hot, let it cool to warm | Recommends oil "not be above 100F"; not recommended over 175 °F | Push the firm tube to the bottom of the pan "without jamming" it; lists specific models it is not compatible with for oil changes | Not stated on the instruction page |
| Griot's Garage Oil/Liquid Extractor | Run a cold engine about 5 minutes; let a hot one cool | None stated as a number; hot oil "can melt or destroy this product" | Choose the tube diameter that fits the dipstick hole | Not stated in the manual text |
| West Marine Extractor 11097714 | Warm the engine up for five minutes | None stated | Main tube 11/32 in. (9.8 mm), extension 1/4 in. (6.7 mm) | 2.9 qt (2.7 L) |
Three things come out of that table.
The temperature advice conflicts, and none of it is checkable with what is in the box. Mityvac tells you to idle to normal operating temperature and also not to extract above 176 °F. Motive recommends staying at or below 100 °F. Griot's and West Marine give a time, five minutes of running, and no number. None of the four supplies a thermometer or tells you how to know the oil temperature at the bottom of a sump. The practical reading: follow the instructions of the extractor you actually buy, and if you want warm, flowing oil without risking the tool's plastic, the cautious end of these instructions is a short warm-up on a cold engine, not a hot engine straight off a drive.
The tube has to reach the bottom of the pan, and you will not know whether it does until you try. Mityvac, Motive and Griot's all say the tube goes to the bottom of the oil pan. Mityvac says to stop pushing "if any force is recognized." So buy an extractor from a seller whose return terms you have checked, because a tube that will not pass your dipstick tube makes the whole tool useless on that car.
Tank size is a hard limit, and it varies more than you might expect. The West Marine unit lists 2.9 quarts. The 2010 Mityvac manual lists 8.8 liters and tells you to empty and restart above 8 liters of crankcase capacity. Check your owner's manual for your engine's oil capacity, then buy a tank bigger than that number, or accept emptying it partway through.
Sources: Mityvac MV7201 user manual, SKF edition and Form 801673, 2010 edition; Motive Products extractor instructions; Griot's Garage Oil/Liquid Extractor manual; West Marine Extractor owner's manual. Two limits: we read the text that could be extracted from each document, so anything printed only in an image would be missed, and the Mityvac copies we read are hosted by retailers, not on a Mityvac site.
Extraction is a trade, not an upgrade
An extractor removes the need to lift the car and open the drain plug. It does not remove the filter change, and it adds three new ways for the job to fail: the tube does not fit, the oil is too cold to flow or too hot for the tool, or the tank is smaller than your sump. None of those failures puts a car above you, which is the real case for it, though hot oil can still burn. The drain route's failures, a car slipping off a jack or a stripped plug, are worse.
So the honest rule is short. If your filter is on top and your dipstick tube accepts the tube, an extractor can take the lifting out of the job. If your filter is underneath, the extractor saves you the drain plug and you still need the lifting gear, so buy the drain-route tools first.
Lifting gear is the expensive half of the drain route
If you need to raise the car, use ramps or a floor jack with jack stands, and chock the wheels that stay on the ground. A jack lifts; it does not hold. We explain why in a floor jack is not a support, and never work under a car held only by a jack.
Ramps are the common choice for oil changes because they need no jack at all. Read the rating and limits on the ones you buy, because they are specific. Race Ramps' instructions for its RR-40 Sport Ramps, as one example, say: "Do not exceed the rated weight capacity of 3,000 lbs. maximum axle capacity." The same document limits tire width to 8 inches and says "Only use on dry, level, hard surfaces. Do not use if tires are wet." It also tells you to use a single pair at the front or rear, never two ramps on one side (Race Ramps RR-40 instructions). We compare ramp ratings in car ramps for an oil change and stand mechanisms in jack stands for a home garage.
The other fluid jobs, and the one tool each adds
Once the oil-change shelf exists, most other fluid work adds a single tool rather than a new kit. We are not saying any of these services is due on your car; that is your owner's manual's call.
- Gear oil in a manual gearbox or differential. The fill hole often sits above the drain, so you need a pump or a large syringe to push fluid up into it. See fluid transfer pumps for gear oil.
- Brake fluid. A bleeder kit, or a second person. Brakes are a safety system, so read brake bleeder kits before deciding to do it at home at all.
- Grease points. Many modern cars have none, and the gun is only worth buying if yours does. See grease guns for a home garage.
- Coolant. A drain pan you never use for oil, a funnel, and possibly a flush kit or a spill-free funnel. Coolant is toxic and goes in its own container.
The part people skip: getting rid of it
Used oil goes to a collection point in a sealed container, and used coolant is a separate stream that never goes in the same jug. Our guide on how to dispose of used motor oil and coolant covers the containers and the rules, and garage floor oil absorbent covers the stain on the concrete. Wear safety glasses for any work under the car, because drips fall toward your face.
Frequently asked questions
What is the minimum I need to change my own oil?
On the drain route: a drain pan, a wrench or socket for the plug, a filter wrench, a funnel, gloves, eye protection and a sealed container for the old oil, plus ramps or a jack with stands if you cannot reach the plug from the ground. On the extraction route, swap the pan and plug wrench for an extractor, if your engine accepts the tube.
Can an oil extractor replace a drain pan completely?
Only if your filter is reachable from above. If the filter is underneath, you still need a pan to catch what it releases and a safe way to reach it.
How warm should the oil be for an extractor?
Follow your extractor's own instructions, because makers disagree. Among the four we read, Motive recommends oil no hotter than 100 °F, while Mityvac says to idle to normal operating temperature but not to extract above 176 °F.
Will an oil extractor fit my car?
The makers cannot promise it. Mityvac's manual says engine and dipstick differences may make it impossible to use on every vehicle, and to stop if the tube meets resistance. Check the seller's return terms before you buy.
Do I need a torque wrench for an oil change?
The drain plug has a specified torque in your vehicle's service information. Whether you need a torque wrench to meet it is a separate buying decision, and we do not give torque values for any vehicle.